The Supreme Court of Canada: Formation, Role, Function, and Importance in the Judicial System
The Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) stands as the highest court in the nation, serving as the final authority on legal matters and constitutional interpretation. Its decisions are binding across Canada and shape the development of law in the country. Understanding the formation, role, and function of the Supreme Court of Canada, as well as its place in the broader Canadian judicial system, is essential to appreciating its critical importance.
Formation of the Supreme Court of Canada
The Supreme Court of Canada was formally created in 1875, eight years after Canadian Confederation in 1867. At the time, Canada’s judicial system was fragmented, with no unified court of final appeal. Legal matters were initially adjudicated by provincial courts, and appeals could ultimately be sent to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council (JCPC) in Britain, which remained the highest court of appeal for Canada until 1949.
The British North America Act (BNA Act) of 1867, which established Canada as a self-governing Dominion within the British Empire, gave the new Canadian Parliament the authority to establish a general court of appeal. After years of debate and opposition, particularly from Quebec, which feared a federal court might infringe on provincial jurisdiction, Prime Minister Alexander Mackenzie’s Liberal government passed the Supreme and Exchequer Court Act in 1875. This Act established both the Supreme Court and the Exchequer Court (later merged into the Federal Court of Canada). At first, however, the court was not seen as the final word on legal matters, as appeals could still be made to the JCPC.
In 1949, the Canadian Parliament amended the Supreme Court Act to eliminate appeals to the Privy Council, making the Supreme Court of Canada the highest judicial authority in the country. This was a significant moment in Canadian legal history, signaling the country’s full judicial independence.
Role and Function of the Supreme Court
The Supreme Court of Canada serves several key functions. Its primary role is to act as the court of last resort for legal disputes in Canada. As the ultimate appellate court, it reviews decisions made by lower courts to ensure that the law has been applied correctly. These reviews can cover a wide range of legal issues, including criminal, civil, and constitutional matters.
The Supreme Court’s most critical role, however, lies in interpreting the Constitution and safeguarding the rule of law. In particular, since the adoption of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms in 1982, the Supreme Court has played a pivotal role in interpreting the Charter’s provisions and ensuring that government actions comply with these fundamental rights. The court's interpretation of constitutional law profoundly affects Canadian society, shaping everything from individual rights and freedoms to the division of powers between federal and provincial governments.
The Court’s decisions are final and binding, meaning they must be followed by all other Canadian courts. Its interpretations of laws and the Constitution set legal precedents, guiding future judicial decisions. Moreover, the Supreme Court also has an advisory role: it can issue advisory opinions (also called "reference cases") at the request of the federal government on major constitutional or legal questions, helping to clarify issues before they escalate into legal conflicts.
Composition and Appointment Process
The Supreme Court of Canada is composed of nine justices, including a Chief Justice, all of whom are appointed by the Governor General on the advice of the Prime Minister. This process ensures that the executive branch has a key role in shaping the composition of the judiciary, though appointments are for life, with justices mandated to retire at the age of 75. This security of tenure ensures that judges are able to operate free from political pressure, upholding the principle of judicial independence.
The composition of the court reflects Canada's regional diversity and its bijural legal system (the coexistence of civil law and common law). By tradition, three of the nine justices must come from Quebec, where the civil law system prevails, while the other six are selected from common law provinces. Typically, three justices are chosen from Ontario, two from Western Canada, and one from the Atlantic provinces. This regional representation ensures that the court remains sensitive to Canada’s geographical and legal diversity.
In 2016, the federal government introduced reforms to make the appointment process more transparent and merit-based. The reforms included the creation of an independent advisory board that screens potential candidates and provides a shortlist of nominees to the Prime Minister, who then makes the final selection. The government also committed to ensuring that the appointments reflect gender balance and diversity, with an emphasis on appointing judges who are bilingual in both of Canada’s official languages, English and French.
How the Supreme Court Works
The Supreme Court of Canada hears cases that are brought before it either by leave (permission) or by automatic right. Most cases come to the court through leave, which means that litigants must apply to the court for permission to appeal a decision from a lower court. In deciding whether to grant leave, the court considers whether the case raises a question of public importance, involves a significant legal issue, or presents an opportunity to clarify the law. Only a small fraction of applications for leave to appeal are accepted each year. In criminal cases where a provincial court of appeal has made a split decision, the litigants have an automatic right of appeal to the Supreme Court.
The court hears arguments from lawyers representing both sides of a case and may also allow interveners (third parties with a vested interest in the issue) to present their views. After hearing the arguments, the justices deliberate and write their decisions, often issuing multiple opinions (majority, concurring, and dissenting). The decision of the majority becomes the law of the land, while dissenting and concurring opinions are considered persuasive but do not carry the force of law.
Cases before the Supreme Court typically address complex legal questions, including constitutional matters, rights under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, criminal law, administrative law, and civil disputes. A hallmark of the Court's role is its ability to balance the individual rights of citizens with the public interest, as well as mediate between federal and provincial powers.
The Supreme Court's Role in the Judicial System
As the highest court in the land, the Supreme Court of Canada occupies a unique and crucial role within the Canadian judicial system. Below the Supreme Court are the provincial and territorial courts, which handle the majority of criminal, civil, and family cases. In addition, there are specialized federal courts, such as the Federal Court and the Tax Court of Canada, which handle cases that fall under federal jurisdiction, including immigration and tax law.
The Supreme Court ensures uniformity in the interpretation and application of law across Canada by hearing appeals from both provincial and federal courts. It serves as a unifying force, harmonizing diverse legal interpretations from different regions and legal traditions within Canada. This role is particularly important given Canada’s dual legal system, where Quebec follows civil law while the rest of Canada uses common law.
Another crucial aspect of the Supreme Court’s function is its role in the evolution of Canadian constitutional law. Since the adoption of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms in 1982, the Court has had the authority to strike down federal and provincial laws that violate constitutional rights. This has given the Court significant influence over government policy, particularly in areas such as equality rights, freedom of expression, and criminal law.
The Supreme Court’s Impact on Canadian Society
The Supreme Court of Canada has played a defining role in shaping modern Canadian society. Its decisions have touched on some of the most pressing social and legal issues of the day, including same-sex marriage, Indigenous land rights, freedom of speech, and assisted dying. Through its interpretation of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, the Court has acted as a guardian of individual rights and freedoms, reinforcing the protections enshrined in the Constitution.
One of the most significant rulings in Canadian history was the Reference re Secession of Quebec (1998), in which the Supreme Court clarified the legal framework surrounding the possibility of Quebec's secession from Canada. The ruling affirmed that while Quebec had no legal right to unilaterally declare independence, the Canadian government would be required to negotiate in good faith if a clear majority of Quebecers voted in favor of secession. This decision underscored the Supreme Court's role in mediating Canada’s complex federalism and its influence on national unity.
Other landmark cases include R. v. Morgentaler (1988), which struck down Canada’s abortion law, and Carter v. Canada (2015), which decriminalized physician-assisted dying under specific circumstances. These cases, among others, demonstrate the Supreme Court’s power to shape public policy and its role as a forum for resolving fundamental questions about justice and rights in Canadian society.
The Supreme Court of Canada, since its formation in 1875, has evolved into a cornerstone of the Canadian legal system and society. Its role in ensuring the consistent application of law, interpreting the Constitution, and safeguarding the rights and freedoms of Canadians places it at the center of the country’s democratic framework. As the highest court in the land, its rulings carry immense weight, influencing not only the legal landscape but also the political, social, and cultural life of Canada. Through its judgments, the Supreme Court of Canada continues to reflect and shape the values of Canadian society, ensuring that the principles of justice, fairness, and equality are upheld for all citizens.
Cite Article : Reference: www.canadahistory.com/sections/documents/documents.html
Source: NA