The economic development of Canada in the late 19th and early 20th centuries reflects the country's dynamic regional growth and the contrasting paths of industrialization, resource extraction, and agricultural expansion. As the western provinces transformed into the breadbasket of the British Empire, providing vast quantities of wheat and grain, and the Yukon became synonymous with precious metals during the Klondike Gold Rush, Ontario and Quebec turned toward industrialization. Meanwhile, the Maritimes and British Columbia sustained the nation’s critical fishing industries, linking Canada's prosperity to both its natural resources and growing industrial might.
The National Policy and the Rise of Canadian Industry
The foundation of this industrial growth was set by the National Policy of 1879, introduced by Prime Minister John A. Macdonald. This policy was designed to foster domestic manufacturing by imposing high tariffs on imported goods, primarily from the United States. The protectionist nature of the policy allowed Canadian industries to grow without the fear of being overwhelmed by cheaper American products. Wilfrid Laurier, who followed Macdonald as Prime Minister, chose to continue this practice, emphasizing the importance of nurturing Canada's industrial base rather than pursuing reciprocity agreements with the U.S.
The continuation of high tariffs became a cornerstone of Canadian economic policy. Industrialists in Ontario and Quebec, who had benefited from the shelter provided by these tariffs, aggressively campaigned for their maintenance, warning of potential job losses and the economic devastation that could occur if U.S. companies were allowed to undercut Canadian prices. These companies argued that U.S. firms, if unchecked, could monopolize Canadian markets and strip the nation of its natural resources, leaving Canadian workers at the mercy of foreign powers.
Growth of Monopolies and the Age of Industrial Titans
The protection of Canadian industries under the National Policy had profound consequences. Rather than fostering widespread competition, the high tariffs led to the rise of large monopolies and oligopolies in various sectors of the Canadian economy. Major Canadian companies like Maple Leaf, Massey Harris, Algoma Steel, Imperial Oil, and Dominion Textiles emerged as dominant players, often merging with or absorbing smaller competitors to consolidate their market power. These companies not only controlled their respective industries but also exerted considerable influence over the Canadian economy as a whole.
This was the age of the "robber barons", a period where industrial magnates wielded vast amounts of economic and political power. Canadian industrialists, much like their American counterparts, often prioritized profit maximization over fair business practices. They maintained high prices, stifled potential competition, and frequently engaged in anti-labor practices, such as breaking unions and enforcing wage concessions from their workers. The monopolistic control over entire sectors allowed them to exploit both their employees and consumers, a practice that was largely tolerated by a government keen on securing the economic stability and political support of big business.
Foreign Investment and Economic Dependence
While the high tariffs successfully protected Canadian industries from direct competition with American companies, they did little to prevent foreign ownership of Canadian resources and businesses. The government actively encouraged foreign investment, particularly from Britain and the United States, as a means of developing the nation’s vast natural resources. This influx of foreign capital was instrumental in building infrastructure, such as railroads, and in supporting the growth of industries like mining, steel production, and energy.
British and American investors were more than willing to pour money into Canadian enterprises, securing control over many key industries, especially in resource extraction. For example, the Canadian oil industry was heavily influenced by American companies, and significant portions of Canada’s mineral wealth were developed through British financing. While foreign investment contributed to Canada’s rapid industrialization, it also sparked concerns about economic sovereignty. Canadians began to worry that their country’s wealth and resources were being controlled by external forces, with profits often flowing out of the country rather than being reinvested domestically.
Early Attempts at Regulation
The growth of monopolies and the increasing influence of foreign investors prompted efforts to regulate the excesses of unchecked capitalism. As early as 1889, the Canadian government passed laws aimed at breaking up monopolies and oligopolies, but these measures proved largely ineffective. Powerful corporations, often supported by political allies, found ways to circumvent or ignore the regulations, allowing them to continue their dominance over the Canadian economy.
Recognizing the need for more substantial intervention, Wilfrid Laurier’s government passed the Combines Investigation Act in 1910, which was designed to address the anti-competitive practices of large corporations. However, like earlier legislation, the Combines Investigation Act was weakly enforced and did little to curtail the power of big business. The rise of large monopolistic companies continued well into the mid-20th century, with industrial titans operating virtually unchecked.
The Impact on Canadian Workers and the Economy
The consolidation of industries under a few powerful companies had significant social and economic implications. For Canadian workers, the dominance of monopolies meant limited job security and reduced bargaining power. With few alternatives available, workers often had no choice but to accept low wages, poor working conditions, and the suppression of unionization efforts. The lack of competition also resulted in higher prices for consumers, as large corporations set prices with little fear of being undercut by rivals.
Moreover, the concentration of economic power in the hands of a few companies created regional imbalances. While Ontario and Quebec thrived as centers of industry, other parts of the country, particularly the Maritimes and Western Canada, were left behind. The National Policy disproportionately benefited the industrial heartland of the nation, leading to calls for more equitable economic policies that would address the needs of all Canadians.
Long-Term Effects and the Role of Free Trade
Despite these challenges, the Canadian industrial landscape remained dominated by monopolistic companies well into the 1950s. It wasn’t until the introduction of more effective regulatory frameworks and the reduction of trade barriers that significant changes began to take place. The eventual implementation of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) in the 1990s played a crucial role in opening up Canadian markets to greater competition, both from within North America and beyond. With the reduction of tariffs, Canadian companies were forced to innovate and become more efficient, while foreign competition helped to lower prices for consumers.
Conclusion: A Legacy of Industrialization
The industrialization of Ontario and Quebec during the late 19th and early 20th centuries marked a critical phase in the development of modern Canada. The protectionist policies of the National Policy allowed domestic industries to grow, but they also fostered monopolistic practices that stifled competition and limited economic opportunities for Canadian workers. The heavy reliance on foreign investment raised concerns about the country’s economic independence, while the regional disparities in wealth and development sowed the seeds of future political and economic challenges.
Canada’s journey from a protected economy to a more open and competitive market is a testament to its ability to adapt to changing global realities. The legacy of this period of industrial expansion, marked by both the successes and failures of Canadian capitalism, continues to shape the nation’s economic policies and social fabric. Today, while Canadian industries are more diversified and competitive, the debates over foreign ownership, corporate regulation, and regional economic balance remain central to discussions about the country’s economic future.
Cite Article : www.canadahistory.com/sections/documents